Statement on FOX Sports: Dustin Colquitt – the veteran punter of the Kansas City Chiefs – called the 2024–2025 Super Bowl champion Philadelphia Eagles “the most unconvincing champion in many years,” while also criticizing their “Tush Push” tactic as “ugly” and “damaging to the true spirit of sports.” “I played nearly two decades in a position few people pay attention to, but I know the value of a truly earned victory. And this isn’t one.” – Colquitt stated.

The Philadelphia Eagles may have lifted the Lombardi Trophy at the end of the 2024–2025 NFL season, but not everyone is applauding. In a bold and unexpected statement aired on FOX Sports, former Kansas City Chiefs punter Dustin Colquitt stirred controversy by calling the reigning Super Bowl champions “the most unconvincing champion in many years,” igniting fierce debate across the football world.

Colquitt, a respected veteran who spent 15 years punting for the Chiefs and played a total of 17 seasons in the NFL, didn’t hold back. During the segment, he pointed fingers at the Eagles’ now-infamous “Tush Push” — a quarterback sneak formation used repeatedly throughout the season — labeling it “ugly” and “damaging to the true spirit of sports.”

“I played nearly two decades in a position few people pay attention to, but I know the value of a truly earned victory,” Colquitt said. “And this isn’t one.”

A Direct Hit to the Champs

The Eagles’ Super Bowl run was statistically dominant, with a powerful offensive line, standout performances from quarterback Jalen Hurts, and a defense that held strong in the postseason. But it was their reliance on the “Tush Push” — also known as the quarterback sneak push or Brotherly Shove — that drew increasing criticism from fans, analysts, and now former players.

The tactic involves the quarterback getting a direct push from multiple teammates behind him in short-yardage situations, essentially forming a human wedge. The Eagles used the play with great success, converting over 90% of short-yardage attempts using the formation.

Critics, like Colquitt, argue that the move skirts the edge of sportsmanship.

“It’s not creative. It’s not athleticism. It’s just brute force, and it turns the game into a rugby match,” Colquitt added. “I’ve seen great teams earn victories through precision, timing, and skill — not by just shoving a pile forward.”

Fans and Analysts React

Social media erupted in the hours following the segment, with fans split between defending their team and calling Colquitt’s comments disrespectful.

“Colquitt is just salty. The Eagles played within the rules. If you don’t like it, stop it.”
— @FlyEaglesFly92

“Finally someone said it. That ‘Tush Push’ isn’t football — it’s a cheat code. Good on Dustin for speaking up.”
— @GridironTraditionalist

Former players also weighed in, with some supporting Colquitt’s viewpoint and others defending the Eagles.

Hall of Fame offensive lineman Alan Faneca tweeted:

“Games are won in the trenches. If your line can’t stop a 1-yard push, don’t cry about it. That’s football.”

Meanwhile, retired defensive end Chris Long, who won a Super Bowl with the Eagles in 2018, called Colquitt’s take “bitter and misguided.”

“Calling them unconvincing champions is just lazy,” Long said during his podcast. “They dominated the NFC, beat the top teams, and got it done. Doesn’t matter how — it matters that they did.”

The NFL’s Ongoing Debate

The “Tush Push” has been a point of contention within the NFL for over two seasons now. Several owners and coaches have reportedly lobbied the league to consider banning or restricting the play, citing player safety and competitive imbalance. However, the league has so far allowed it to continue, deeming it a legal — if controversial — tactic.

Colquitt’s comments could reignite discussions during upcoming NFL Competition Committee meetings, where rule changes for the 2025–2026 season will be reviewed.

A Punter’s Perspective

While punters rarely find themselves at the center of headline-making drama, Colquitt’s tenure in the league earned him respect for his consistency, leadership, and football IQ. He was part of Kansas City’s 2019 Super Bowl-winning team and played under some of the league’s top special teams coordinators.

“I may not have scored touchdowns or made highlight reels,” Colquitt said, “but I’ve been on teams that earned every inch with grit, not gimmicks.”

His strong words seem to come from a place of old-school football tradition — a belief in fundamentals, fair play, and respect for the craft.

Looking Ahead

Whether fans agree with Dustin Colquitt or not, his comments have thrown fuel on an already simmering fire about the evolution of the NFL’s playing style. As the league continues to evolve — with offenses pushing the boundaries of creativity and power — debates about what constitutes “true football” are unlikely to fade.

As for the Philadelphia Eagles, they remain focused on defending their title. If they continue to dominate the trenches and rack up wins — with or without the “Tush Push” — it’s hard to argue with results.

But with voices like Colquitt’s growing louder, the league may be forced to decide whether the game is changing for the better — or losing something in the process.