New York Giants Regret Passing on Shedeur Sanders—Joe Thomas Reveals the Real Reason, and It’s Not Football!

The 2025 NFL season hasn’t even started, and the New York Giants are already feeling the heat. While their quarterback situation crumbles, a bombshell from Browns legend Joe Thomas has NFL executives scrambling for damage control. The truth? The Giants passed on Shedeur Sanders not because of his talent, but because of fear—and now, they’re paying the price.

Joe Thomas Drops the Truth Bomb

Joe Thomas, the Hall of Fame tackle who protected more quarterbacks than anyone in Browns history, just told the world what fans have suspected for months: Shedeur Sanders has a higher ceiling than most quarterbacks in the league. He’s accurate, he’s a playmaker, and he thrives under pressure. “He’d be great for the league,” Thomas said, “because the league wants eyeballs on it.”

But Thomas didn’t stop there. He revealed that Sanders’ fall to the fifth round had nothing to do with his ability. Teams like the Giants were scared—not of his arm, but of his timeline, his confidence, and the media circus that comes with being Deion Sanders’ son. They wanted quiet, controllable quarterbacks—not someone who could shake up the system.

.

.

.

The Giants’ Draft Day Disaster

Instead of taking the most accurate quarterback in college football, the Giants grabbed Jackson Dart and hoped for the best. Now, they’re stuck with a washed-up Russell Wilson and a rookie not ready for the New York spotlight. Eight of their first twelve opponents made the playoffs last year. The media is already predicting a bottom-five finish, and fans are furious.

Meanwhile, Cleveland played it perfectly. While other teams dodged the “Sanders Circus,” the Browns traded up and got a potential franchise quarterback for backup value. They’re protecting their investment, letting Joe Flacco steady the ship while Shedeur learns and develops—just like Aaron Rodgers behind Brett Favre, or Patrick Mahomes behind Alex Smith.

NFL Executives Exposed

NBC Sports and Fox Sports both reported that many teams had “character concerns” about Shedeur because he didn’t play their pre-draft games. He skipped certain workouts, didn’t answer questions the way they wanted, and refused to bow to the system. Travis Kelce called out these cowardly executives, demanding the Browns “give the people what they want.”

The truth is, the NFL punished Shedeur for having standards, for believing in himself, and for having a father who wouldn’t let teams disrespect his son. It wasn’t about football—it was about control.

Shedeur Sanders Is Ready to Prove Them Wrong

When Shedeur finally got his chance in preseason, he delivered. His debut against Carolina was spectacular, and the football world took notice. But in his final preseason game, the Browns put him with third and fourth stringers, setting him up to struggle. Why? Because too much success would create pressure to start him over Flacco. Cleveland is playing 4D chess—protecting Sanders while the rest of the league scrambles.

And make no mistake: the fans are hungry. Travis Kelce, LeBron James, and even casual NFL viewers want to see Shedeur succeed. The excitement is real. The only ones who don’t see it are the executives who passed on him.

The Giants’ Regret Will Only Grow

When Shedeur finally gets his shot—and it’s coming sooner than anyone expects—the Giants will be watching from the sidelines, wishing they’d made a different choice. Russell Wilson looks washed, Jackson Dart isn’t ready, and the Giants are staring down the barrel of another lost season.

Every touchdown Shedeur throws, every highlight reel play, will be a reminder of what New York could have had. The Browns got the steal of the century, while the Giants are left with regret.

Do you think the Giants made the biggest draft mistake in years? Smash that like button if you agree, and subscribe for every twist and turn in the Shedeur Sanders saga. This story is just getting started—and trust me, you don’t want to miss what happens next.