Breanna Stewart’s Postgame Smirk Toward Caitlin Clark Sparks Controversy: Was It a Jab at Her All-Star Captaincy?

A single moment after the buzzer has set the internet ablaze. Following a hard-fought victory over Caitlin Clark’s team, cameras caught New York Liberty star Breanna Stewart glancing at Clark and offering what many described as a dismissive smirk or sly grin. The brief expression has triggered a flurry of speculation and debate, with some fans and analysts interpreting it as subtle shade aimed at Clark’s recent selection as an All-Star Game captain.

The Moment That Went Viral

As Stewart walked past Clark following the game, she appeared to glance in her direction and crack a slight smile—one that many on social media claim was less about sportsmanship and more about sarcasm. The clip, shared widely on X (formerly Twitter), quickly drew thousands of reactions, with hashtags like #StewieSmirk and #ClarkCaptain trending overnight.

“Breanna definitely meant that,” one fan wrote. “That was a ‘so you’re the All-Star captain now?’ kind of look.”

Others saw it differently: “Come on. That’s just a competitor soaking in a win,” another user replied. “Don’t read too much into it.”

Context: Clark’s All-Star Captaincy Controversy

Caitlin Clark, the rookie sensation from Indiana Fever, was recently voted as one of the captains for the 2025 WNBA All-Star Game. While the selection was celebrated by her massive fan base, some WNBA veterans and fans questioned the decision, citing her inexperience and the fact that she’s still learning the pace and structure of the pro game.

Breanna Stewart, a two-time WNBA MVP and established league leader, was not named captain this year—despite her continued dominance on the court and leadership for one of the league’s top teams.

That contrast has fueled interpretations of Stewart’s postgame smile as a subtle critique—an elite veteran possibly throwing a little shade at a rising star who many feel is being handed accolades too soon.

A Deeper Rivalry Brewing?

While there has been no public animosity between Stewart and Clark, moments like this highlight the subtle tensions brewing as the WNBA enters a new era. Clark, with her massive college following and growing influence, represents the future of the league. Stewart, meanwhile, is part of a generation that helped carry the WNBA to where it is today.

Some argue that these tensions are natural—and even healthy—for the sport.

“This is competition,” said former WNBA player and analyst Swin Cash. “You don’t have to be best friends out there. That smirk? That’s just the edge that great players carry. Clark’s gotta wear it and come back stronger.”

Neither Side Has Commented—Yet

Neither Stewart nor Clark has addressed the incident directly. Clark, as usual, handled the postgame press with grace, focusing on her team’s performance. Stewart was asked about the moment but declined to elaborate.

Conclusion

Whether it was playful banter, competitive fire, or a pointed message, Breanna Stewart’s postgame expression has added a new layer of intrigue to an already fascinating WNBA season. As the league continues to grow in both viewership and star power, moments like this only add to the drama—and give fans something to talk about long after the final buzzer.