From Terrible to Incredible: Indiana Fever Pull Off Wildest Comeback — But Is Sophie Cunningham Done for the Season?

What started as a nightmare quickly transformed into one of the most unforgettable comebacks in WNBA history. On Sunday night, the Indiana Fever rallied from a 21-point second-half deficit to defeat the Connecticut Sun 99–93 in overtime—a game defined by injury, resilience, and one player’s career-defining performance.

A Devastating Blow Early On

Midway through the second quarter, guard Sophie Cunningham went down with a painful knee injury after Connecticut’s Bria Hartley accidentally collided with her during a fast break. Cunningham immediately clutched her right knee in agony and was helped off the floor, unable to return. The injury cast a shadow over the game, and with key stars like Caitlin Clark, Aari McDonald, and Sydney Colson already sidelined, it felt like the Fever’s season was slipping away. The team now awaits MRI results, with fans and coaches bracing for the possibility that Cunningham could miss the remainder of the season.

Mitchell Erupts and Changes the Narrative

Then came the spark that flipped the script: Kelsey Mitchell. After a quiet first half, Mitchell exploded for 34 points in the second, finishing with a career-high 38—marking the highest-scoring performance in the WNBA this season. She was unstoppable in overtime, draining clutch shots that fueled Indiana’s unbelievable run and stunned the Connecticut crowd.

Mitchell’s outburst broke the franchise record for most 30-point games in a Fever jersey, surpassing WNBA legend Tamika Catchings. With their backs against the wall, it was Mitchell’s fearless offense that gave Indiana a fighting chance—and ultimately, a statement win.

Support Cast Steps Up

It wasn’t just Mitchell who delivered. Center Aliyah Boston was a force on both ends, notching 14 points, 13 rebounds, and five assists. Veteran Natasha Howard added 18 points and nine boards, while newly signed Odyssey Sims contributed 19 points and seven assists in a gritty performance that showed just how much depth this team still has, even with half its core missing.

Coach White in Tears

After the buzzer sounded, head coach Stephanie White was visibly emotional. From the panic of watching Cunningham go down to the pride of witnessing one of the gutsiest team efforts of the season, it was a night she—and Fever fans—won’t forget. “They bring it out of each other,” White said postgame, praising her players’ heart and toughness.

Is Sophie Out for the Season?

As of now, no official confirmation has been made regarding the severity of Cunningham’s injury. Early signs are worrying, but the team is awaiting full medical evaluation. Depending on the diagnosis, her recovery could range from a few weeks to a season-ending layoff. With the Fever in a tight playoff race and sitting at 19–16, any additional loss of personnel could have serious implications.

The Road Ahead

Despite the uncertainty, one thing is clear: this Fever team refuses to fold. Whether it’s battling injuries, erasing a 21-point hole, or surviving in overtime, they’ve proven they have the heart—and the talent—to fight to the end. Sunday’s win was not just a comeback—it was a statement.

Now, all eyes turn to Sophie Cunningham’s diagnosis. Her fate could shape the final chapter of Indiana’s season. But for now, the team—and their fans—can celebrate one of the most incredible turnarounds the WNBA has seen in years.